Blog & News

New York PTET in 2027: The Practitioner Math After the SALT Cap Change

State and Local Taxes

Hunter Moore, CPA, CITP13 min read

A partnership makes one NY PTET election, but the impact on its partners can vary. With the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) changing the SALT cap, the election is worth a moment of consideration. In today's blog, we'll walk through an example that shows the differences from partner to partner. We'll then cover how the March 15 election and estimated payments operate, and where the credit can fail on a personal return.

What is the NY PTET election?

The New York pass-through entity tax traces its roots to 2017's Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA). Beginning in 2018, the TCJA limited an individual's deduction for state and local taxes to $10,000. With the stroke of a pen, many pass-through owners lost a sizeable deduction from their personal returns.

Many states responded by enacting the option to pay tax at the entity level. Connecticut passed the first pass-through entity tax in May 2018, and in November 2020 the IRS confirmed that such payments are deducted by the entity and don't count against an owner's limit. The following April, New York enacted its PTET, which came into effect for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2021.

The OBBBA raised the cap but also added a phase-out limitation. As the March 15, 2027 election deadline draws closer, understanding how the two interact can lead to tangible benefits for your clients.

The 2027 math: why elect-or-not is now a per-client decision

Our example today follows Ridgeline Engineering LLC, an Albany partnership with $3,000,000 of income for calendar year 2027. Its three partners are New York residents, with Ana holding 72%, Ben holding 18%, and Cara holding 10%. We'll set out the cap, compute each partner's deduction with and without the election, and show the tax impact for all.

The 2027 SALT cap

Rule2027 amount

Cap*

$40,804

Floor

$10,000

Modified AGI phase-out range

$510,050 to $612,730

Reduction

30 cents for each dollar above $510,050

*For tax years after 2029, the cap is $10,000 for every taxpayer.

The 2027 cap and threshold are 101% of the 2026 amounts, as the statute provides for 2027 through 2029. The IRS did not restate them in Rev. Proc. 2026-35, which set the other 2027 figures, including the tax brackets used below.

Ridgeline's three partners

Each partner files jointly, pays $15,000 of property tax, and has enough other itemized deductions, such as mortgage interest and charitable gifts, to itemize with or without the election. To keep the comparison even, we assume the New York income tax on a partner's share is the same amount whether the partner pays it personally or the firm pays it under the election. At these income levels, the 2027 personal cap is $10,000 for Ana, $31,819 for Ben, and $40,804 for Cara. Federal savings use each partner's marginal rate under the 2027 brackets and leave out the qualified business income deduction.

AnaBenCara

Share of firm income

$2,160,000

$540,000

$300,000

New York income tax on that share

$168,120

$42,030

$23,350

Property tax

15,000

15,000

15,000

Total state and local tax

183,120

57,030

38,350

Less: amount over the personal cap

(173,120)

(25,211)

0

Deductible without the election

$10,000

$31,819

$38,350

Deducted by the electing firm

$168,120

$42,030

$23,350

Property tax deducted personally

10,000

15,000

15,000

Deductible with the election

178,120

57,030

38,350

Less: deductible without the election

(10,000)

(31,819)

(38,350)

Added deduction

$168,120

$25,211

$0

Federal marginal rate

37%

32%

24%

Federal tax saved

$62,204

$8,068

$0

Ana is above the point where the cap reaches its $10,000 floor, so nearly all of her state income tax moves from lost to deducted.

Ben is inside the phase-out range. His cap is $40,804 less 30% of the $29,950 by which his income exceeds $510,050, and the election recovers the $25,211 he would otherwise lose. Because the pass-through deducts the tax, his share of income, and with it his MAGI, falls to $497,970. That is below $510,050, so his personal cap is the full $40,804, with room left for other state and local taxes beyond his $15,000 of property tax.

Cara is below the phase-out range, and her $38,350 already fits under the cap, so the election changes where her deduction is taken and not how much she deducts.

The entity-level deduction also reduces each partner's qualified business income (QBI) and the related deduction. Be sure to keep that in mind when evaluating your clients' scenarios.

The NY PTET election deadline is March 15

The PTET election must be made annually, from January 1 through March 15. For 2027, the deadline is Monday, March 15, 2027. Every other 2027 New York due date is in our New York tax deadlines calendar.

The statute ties the election to the due date of the first estimated payment. The entity can revoke the election until that payment's due date, but it is irrevocable afterwards. For entities formed after March 15, the organization must wait for the following year.

An electing entity pays its 2027 estimates on these dates.

  • March 15, 2027
  • June 15, 2027
  • September 15, 2027
  • December 15, 2027

Each installment is 25% of the required annual payment, which is the lesser of 90% of the current year's PTET or 100% of the prior year's, and an entity that did not elect for the prior year has no prior-year liability to rely upon. Instead, it must remit 90% of the current year's amount. A first-year entity sizing estimates from the current year should project at the graduated rates, since income over $2,000,000 is taxed at 9.65% or more.

Who can elect, and what is their tax base?

Partnerships, LLCs taxed as partnerships, and New York S corporations are all eligible entities for the PTET election. Sole proprietors, trusts, and single-member LLCs cannot, unless the LLC is taxed as a New York S corporation. While many different entities are eligible to make the election, the entity's structure determines the taxable base.

Electing entityPTE taxable income includes

Partnership

Resident partners' shares of income from all sources, plus nonresident partners' shares of New York source income

Standard S corporation

Shareholders' shares of New York source income only

Resident S corporation

Shareholders' shares of income from all sources

An S corporation gets the resident base only if it certifies upon election that every shareholder is a New York resident. A corporation with even a single nonresident shareholder is a standard S corporation, which requires the entity to source NY amounts. A partnership classifies each partner as a resident or a nonresident for the whole year, with no part-year category.

Only income flowing to direct owners who are individuals, estates, or trusts taxed under New York's personal income tax is eligible. However, income allocated to a corporate partner, a partnership partner, or an S corporation partner stays out of the base, and those taxpayers can neither claim a credit nor pass one through to their owners. A partnership with ineligible partners can still elect, but their income is not taken into account for PTET purposes.

Ridgeline's base is the easy case. All three partners are residents, so the full $3,000,000 is PTE taxable income.

The NY PTET rate schedule

The tax is graduated, and the schedule applies to the entity's total base, not partner by partner.

PTE taxable incomeTax

Not over $2,000,000

6.85%

Over $2,000,000 but not over $5,000,000

$137,000 plus 9.65% of the excess over $2,000,000

Over $5,000,000 but not over $25,000,000

$426,500 plus 10.30% of the excess over $5,000,000

Over $25,000,000

$2,486,500 plus 10.90% of the excess over $25,000,000

Because the schedule runs on the firm's total income, every partner bears the firm's blended rate, 7.78% for Ridgeline ($233,500 ÷ $3,000,000). Cara's 10% share comes to $23,350 ($233,500 × 10%), even though her $300,000 alone would never reach the 9.65% bracket. She isn't disadvantaged in the long run, though, since the refundable credit returns any excess.

Running the election across a client book

The election must be made by a person with authority to bind the entity or sign its returns and is processed through the entity's own Online Services account. The Tax Department states that tax professionals may not opt in on a client's behalf.

The timing turns a March 15 deadline into a February task. For each electing entity, the annual cycle looks like this.

  1. In December and January, run the per-owner math for each pass-through client and agree on the decision.
  2. In January, send each electing client a letter that walks through the Online Services steps and the March 15 deadline, and ask the client to name who will make the election.
  3. Before March 15, collect the confirmation of each election. For an S corporation, confirm whether the resident certification was made.
  4. Size the first estimate from the current-year projection, schedule the ACH debit, and update the projection before the June, September, and December payments.
  5. Before the K-1s are issued, reconcile the payments to the final liability, and tie each owner's share of the credit to the operating agreement and the K-1 allocations.

Adjust the nonresident estimates. An entity ordinarily pays estimated tax for its nonresident individual owners on Form IT-2658. An electing entity may take the PTET credit into account when it computes those payments, which can reduce or eliminate them. It still makes estimated MCTMT payments and estimated payments for any corporate partners.

Extend the PTET return on its own. Form IT-370-PF and Form CT-5.4 don't apply to the PTET return. The entity must request a separate extension online by March 15.

Coordinate the other states. For clients with owners or operations elsewhere, Marble's PTET Election by State: 2026 Complete Reference Guide covers the elections outside New York.

The PTET credit, and where it unravels

Each owner's credit equals the owner's direct share of the tax the entity paid, and it cannot exceed the share the entity reported for that owner on its PTET return. The owner's credit is only as good as the entity's reporting.

When elected, the results cascade through three returns as follows.

FilingTreatment

The entity's NY PTET return

The entity pays New York tax on its owners' shares of income

The entity's federal return

The entity deducts the tax, without regard to an owner's personal SALT limit

Each owner's New York return

The owner claims a refundable credit for a share of the tax the entity paid

The last of those returns takes the most work. Getting the credit from the entity to the owner's New York return follows three general steps.

  1. The entity reports each owner's share. A partnership uses Form IT-204-IP, and an S corporation gives each shareholder a statement.
  2. The owner claims the credit on Form IT-653, filed with Form IT-201, Form IT-203, or a trust's Form IT-205.
  3. The owner adds back to New York income an amount equal to the credit, on Form IT-225. The addback keeps the same tax from producing both a deduction and a credit on the New York return.

If the credit exceeds the owner's tax, the excess is refunded or applied to next year's balance.

One hiccup, though, is that not every owner can claim the credit. The benefit is limited to individuals, estates, and trusts, so a partner that is a corporation, a partnership, or an S corporation gets no credit for its share. A trust keeps the credit on its own return and can't pass it through to its beneficiaries.

Even with a valid election and timely filing, the credit unravels when the entity's allocation to each owner doesn't match the economics. For a partnership, the Department sorts partners into resident and nonresident pools, splits the tax between the two groups, and allocates each pool's tax by profit and loss percentage. An S corporation is simpler, since its tax follows each shareholder's ownership percentage. A partnership with special allocations or guaranteed payments can't rely on profit and loss percentages alone. It has to adjust the allocation so each partner's credit follows the income actually allocated to that partner.

An entity that applies straight ownership percentages to a deal with a special allocation, a guaranteed payment, or a mid-year admission reports allocations that the owners' returns do not support. The mismatch invites scrutiny that could lead to a disallowance of amounts claimed.

NYC PTET: the separate stack

NYC PTET is a second, separate election at a flat 3.876% of city PTE taxable income. It is open only to an entity that has elected the PTET at the state level, and it is made at the same time, in the same online application.

Eligibility and the tax base both depend on residency, not source. A partnership needs at least one city-resident partner, and its base is only those partners' share of income. An S corporation qualifies only if every shareholder is a city resident, and its base is the corporation's income from all sources. The resident owners claim the city credit on the same Form IT-653, regardless of entity.

NYC PTET is in addition to any other tax on the entity, so it doesn't replace the unincorporated business tax for a partnership doing business in the city.

When not to elect

The election isn't worth making when the owners gain little and the entity bears the cost. Here are four situations where electing may not be advantageous.

  • Owners already under the cap. An owner whose modified AGI is below the phase-out range deducts everything personally. Cara is the example from our walkthrough. The election adds filings and paperwork for her without any benefit. Run the numbers before ruling it out, though, because an owner who takes the standard deduction still gains from a deduction taken by the entity.
  • Entity owners. A partnership whose income flows mostly to corporations, partnerships, or S corporations has little or no base, because income allocated to entity owners is left out of the PTET base and they can't claim the credit.
  • Cash. Electing moves the tax onto the entity's calendar, with four estimated payments during the year, often earlier than the owners would pay on their own. Because the entity applies its graduated schedule to the firm's total income, it can also remit more than an owner would owe personally. On Ana's actual return, her New York tax would be about $146,860, against the $168,120 the firm remits on her share. She gets the roughly $21,260 difference back as a refundable credit, but only after she files, and without interest. For a firm that's tight on cash, that timing can outweigh the federal savings.
  • Mixed results. The election is made once and binds every owner for the year. If one partner benefits and another doesn't, as with Ana and Cara, the partners need to have that conversation before March 15, because the choice can't be undone afterward.

Common errors

Six mistakes recur, and the workflow above prevents each of them.

  • Missing March 15 because the client assumed the firm's return extension covered the election. It does not.
  • Omitting the addback on Form IT-225 when the owner claims the credit.
  • Electing the state tax and forgetting the city election, or assuming the city election can be made alone.
  • Reporting credit allocations that ignore special allocations and guaranteed payments.
  • Relying on last year's election for the current year. The election is made annually.
  • Assuming the return extension on Form IT-370-PF or Form CT-5.4 covers the PTET return.

Frequently asked questions about the NY PTET

What is the NY PTET election deadline?

The election must be made online by March 15 of the tax year it covers. For tax year 2027, the deadline is March 15, 2027. The election deadline cannot be extended.

Did the deadline move to September 15?

No. Moving the deadline to September 15 was proposed in the FY 2026 Executive Budget and again in the FY 2027 Executive Budget, but neither proposal passed. March 15 remains the deadline, and September 15 is the due date of the third estimated payment.

Who can make the election?

Only a person authorized to act for the entity can make the election, through the entity's Online Services account. That means a partner or member with authority to bind a partnership, or an authorized officer, manager, or shareholder of an S corporation. A tax professional cannot make the election for a client.

How do PTET estimated payments work?

An electing entity pays four installments, due March 15, June 15, September 15, and December 15 of the tax year. Each is 25% of the required annual payment, which is the lesser of 90% of the current year's tax or 100% of the prior year's. Payments are made online by ACH debit.

How do I claim the PTET credit on my personal return?

Claim your share on Form IT-653, filed with your New York income tax return. The entity reports that share on Form IT-204-IP or, for an S corporation, a shareholder statement. You must also add back an amount equal to the credit on Form IT-225. Any credit above your tax is refunded or applied to next year's tax.

Are guaranteed payments included in the PTET base?

Yes, to the same extent New York taxes them to the partner, and the partner receives the PTET credit tied to them. Retirement payments that New York does not tax at the partner level stay out of the base.

Is the PTET itself included in the base?

Yes. The base is measured before the PTET, so pass-through entity taxes paid and deducted federally during the year are added back. That includes New York PTET, NYC PTET, and substantially similar taxes paid to other states.

Where Marble fits

Tracking which entities elected, which certified, and which owners need a second look takes trusted research. Marble answers each client's PTET questions with citations to the Tax Law and the Department's guidance, and keeps that research organized by client. Sign up for Marble.

This article is a general discussion of certain accounting and tax developments and related topics of interest and should not be relied upon as accounting or tax advice. If you require accounting or tax advice you should consult a qualified practitioner.


For permission to republish this or any other publication, contact support@marble.ai.

Related articles

View more

See what tax work looks like with Marble.

Start researching today or talk to our team about bringing Marble across your firm’s tax workflow.